fried Lebanon bologna sandwich

Fried Lebanon Bologna Sandwich

The Coal Region has a love affair with Lebanon bologna, and I was — and still am — mightily smitten with it as are so many others.


Throughout high school, I tended to eschew the entire “mad-dash then wait-in-line only to have 10 minutes to gulp down lunch” school cafeteria experience. Hence, I usually found myself, brown bag in hand, making my own dining rules through junior and senior high school. My Mom’s lovingly packed lunches better suited my tastes and allowed me to actually enjoy the much needed break between morning and afternoon classes.

When it came to sandwiches, Mom would occasionally get creative, but I had my “holy trinity” of clear favorites; good smokey ham with cheese, Mom’s cold meatloaf, and Lebanon bologna.

Occasionally, I would leave the house in the morning in a rush or pre-occupied, not realizing what my lunch bag held, but one quick whiff after unzipping the closure left no doubt about the contents on Lebanon bologna sandwich day!

I had a certain ritual for eating my Lebanon bologna sandwiches. I would open up the sandwich, tear open the little bag of potato chips Mom always included (usually Marsden’s, made in Pottsville, PA), and pile as many chips onto the top of the Lebanon bologna as humanly possible. I would then replace the top slice of bread and “smoosh” the sandwich flat with the palm of my hand, crushing the chips inside — the perfect lunch for this Coal Region kid!

Now, as much as I loved those Lebanon bologna sandwiches, come days off or summer vacation, fried Lebanon bologna sandwiches took center stage! Consisting of the same ingredients as the beloved cold version, this one featured pan fried Lebanon bologna, but now topped by a melt-y, gooey slice of American cheese.

Depending on her general outlook on life on any given day, Mom would “shake things up” and vary the thickness of the slices when she purchased Lebanon bologna from the local Mom and Pop store. Sometimes the slices were nearly 1/4 inch thick, other times they would be paper thin.

Over the years I adopted the motto, “Any size slice of fried Lebanon bologna is a good slice of fried Lebanon bologna”, although, like my Mom, I change up the thickness of the slices based on split decisions standing in front of the deli counter.

Thicker pan-fried slices tend to retain more of the classic Lebanon bologna taste while frying thinner slices results in a more “frizzled” and “crispy” texture that I find very appealing, so for a long time now, I have leaned more toward the thinly sliced bologna for the hot version of one of my favorite Coal Region comfort foods.

For me, the brands of mayonnaise and yellow mustard used on this sandwich are negotiable, even the brand and style of potato chips have wiggle room, but the one thing that is carved in stone is that using good old-fashioned, super soft and squishy, plain white sandwich bread is an absolute must!

The “Dutchie” in it all

Lebanon bologna resembles salami somewhat in texture and appearance but is an all-beef, semi-dry, fermented, smoked and cured sausage that originated in the Pennsylvania Dutch (German “Deutsch“) communities of Lebanon County, Pennsylvania. It can be traced back to the late 1700’s, and was a well-known and common item by the early 1800’s. The product was strongly influenced by the slow-cured sausages of Western Europe. The name “Lebanon bologna” actually evolved in the 1920’s and ’30’s when several producers of the product were concentrated in Lebanon County.

Lebanon bologna is widely associated with the culinary heritage of both the Pennsylvania Dutch in south-eastern areas of Pennsylvania and into the Coal Region of north-east Pennsylvania. Although I can find it fairly easily in stores here in the south-western portion of PA, it is not nearly as prolific as in Lebanon and Schuylkill counties and the south- and north-eastern portions of Pennsylvania where even small grocery stores are known to carry several different varieties and brands side-by-side at the deli counter and there are some local, independent Lebanon bologna makers.

Traditionally prepared versions of Lebanon bologna are infused with a strong smoky flavor through hardwood smoking. High heat can adversely affect the quality of the finished product, so the meat is cold smoked for several days then tested to ensure that it is at the proper pH level.

Today, Lebanon bologna is produced in a range of styles from “regular”, to “sweet”, double-smoked and even lower sodium.

For another very classic Coal Region dish featuring Lebanon bologna, see my recipe for Lebanon Bologna Roll Ups.

Mail-order Resources


If publishing or referencing this recipe on another website, you may copy/paste the list of ingredients (the only part of a recipe not protected under copyright law.) Link back to this post for the directions (as in “Get The Directions Here”). On SOCIAL MEDIA share only the LINK to this page. Original content, including my recollections, original photographs, stories, and nostalgia are Copyright 2010 to Present, Lori Fogg, All Rights Reserved and may not be used without express written permission. For complete Copyright information, visit the Terms of Use and Copyright Notice page.


Fried Lebanon Bologna Sandwich

Recipe by Lori Fogg, A Coalcracker In The KitchenCourse: Snacks, SandwichesCuisine: Coal Region, PA DutchDifficulty: Easy

Ingredients

  • About 2 1/2 to 3 ounces Sweet or regular Lebanon bologna, sliced thin

  • 2 slices of your favorite white sandwich bread

  • Prepared yellow mustard, to taste

  • Mayonnaise, to taste

  • 1 slice white American cheese

  • About 1/2 ounce of your favorite potato chips or as many as is humanly possible to pile on, your choice!

  • 1/2 Tablespoon butter

  • Optional
  • Sweet pickle slices, about 5 – 6 or to taste

Directions

  • Stack the sliced bologna and cut small slits about 1/4 to 1/3-inch into the edge all around using the point of a sharp knife. (this helps minimize the Lebanon bologna from “cupping” and “curling” when frying and allows for more even browning of the surface.)
  • Spread one side of one slice of bread with yellow mustard, to your taste, set aside. Spread one side of the second piece of bread with mayonnaise, set aside.
  • Heat a non-stick frying pan over medium-high heat. Melt the butter; once is starts to bubble, add the slices of Lebanon bologna, spreading them out in the pan, and fry on one side until crisped, browned and caramelized, about 1 to 3 minutes depending on thickness. Turn and cook on the other side to the same degree of brown. Remove from heat. Bring the slices of fried bologna together in the center of the pan, top with the slice of cheese, and place a lid on the pan for a couple minutes to allow the cheese to start to melt.
  • Place the fried Lebanon bologna and melted cheese on top of the piece of bread spread with the yellow mustard. If adding the sweet pickles, lay the pickle slices on the bread before adding the fried bologna.
  • Pile the potato chips on top of the fried Lebanon bologna, top with the mayonnaise spread piece of bread and “smoosh” down with the palm of your hand, crumbling the chips (and flattening the sandwich!).
  • Slice in half, if desired, and enjoy!

Notes

  • You may also add a slice of American cheese to this sandwich. Place it on top of the fried Lebanon bologna in the pan when you remove it from the heat. Cover the pan with a lid and allow to set for a few minutes until the cheese is melted. Finish assembling the sandwich according to the directions.
Advertisement